In Massachusetts, civil harassment and criminal harassment are distinct legal concepts with different implications, procedures, and penalties.
Civil Harassment
- Civil harassment is not a criminal charge but a civil matter.
- It typically involves unwanted behavior that causes distress but does not rise to the level of a crime.
- Victims can seek a Harassment Prevention Order (a type of restraining order) through the civil courts to legally prevent the harasser from contacting or approaching them.
- While the order itself is civil, violating a Harassment Prevention Order is a criminal offense, which can lead to criminal penalties.
Criminal Harassment
- Criminal harassment is a criminal offense prosecuted by the state.
- Defined under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 265, Section 43A, it requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant:
- Engaged in a knowing pattern of conduct or series of acts over time,
- Directed at a specific person,
- Acted willfully and maliciously,
- Caused serious alarm to the victim,
- And that the conduct would cause a reasonable person to suffer substantial emotional distress.
- The conduct can include in-person acts, phone calls, emails, texts, or other communications.
- The pattern must occur on at least three separate occasions with the intent that the victim knows the acts are directed at them.
- Criminal harassment is punishable by up to 2.5 years in the house of correction or up to 10 years in state prison depending on the circumstances.
Key Differences
| Aspect | Civil Harassment | Criminal Harassment |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Civil matter | Criminal offense |
| Legal remedy | Harassment Prevention Order (restraining order) | Criminal prosecution and potential imprisonment |
| Proof required | Preponderance of evidence (civil standard) | Beyond a reasonable doubt (criminal standard) |
| Penalties for violation | Criminal penalties if order violated | Jail/prison time, fines, probation |
| Conduct threshold | Unwanted behavior causing distress | Repeated, willful, malicious conduct causing serious alarm and emotional distress |
| Number of incidents | Not strictly defined | At least three separate incidents |
Additional Notes
- Criminal harassment differs from stalking, which requires a threat intended to place the victim in imminent fear of death or bodily injury and carries harsher penalties.
- Harassment focuses on emotional distress caused by a pattern of conduct, without necessarily involving physical threats or harm, which distinguishes it from assault.
In summary, civil harassment in Massachusetts is addressed through civil court orders to prevent contact, while criminal harassment involves repeated malicious acts that cause serious emotional distress and can lead to criminal charges and imprisonment. Violating a civil harassment order can itself become a criminal offense, bridging the two areas of law.
🔴 Immediate Actions (Today or ASAP)
- Ensure Your Safety: If you feel threatened or in immediate danger, call 911 or local law enforcement right away.
- Document Incidents: Start writing down every unwanted contact or behavior, including dates, times, places, what happened, and any witnesses. Save all related evidence such as texts, emails, voicemails, social media messages, or photos.
- Limit Contact: Avoid engaging with the harasser. Do not respond to messages or calls, as this can sometimes escalate the situation.
- Consider a Harassment Prevention Order (HPO): If you want to legally stop the harasser from contacting or approaching you, you can file for a civil Harassment Prevention Order in Massachusetts courts. This can be done quickly and may provide immediate protection.
- Contact Local Police: Report any behavior that feels threatening or harassing, especially if it meets the criteria for criminal harassment (repeated, willful, malicious acts causing serious emotional distress).
🟡 Short-Term Steps (This Week)
- File for a Harassment Prevention Order: Visit your local Massachusetts District Court or Probate and Family Court to file for an HPO. You can also ask the court clerk for help with forms and procedures.
- Gather Evidence: Collect and organize all your documentation of harassment incidents, including written records, screenshots, recordings, and witness statements.
- Consult Law Enforcement: Follow up with police about your report and ask about the possibility of criminal charges if the harassment is severe and repeated.
- Seek Legal Advice: Contact a local legal aid organization or a private attorney who specializes in harassment, family law, or criminal law to understand your options and rights.
- Inform Trusted People: Let friends, family, or coworkers know about the situation for support and safety monitoring.
🟢 Strategic Follow-Up (Next 2-4 Weeks or Longer)
- Attend Court Hearings: If you filed for an HPO, attend all scheduled court dates and bring your evidence and witnesses.
- Consider Criminal Charges: If the harassment is ongoing and meets criminal harassment criteria, work with law enforcement and your attorney to pursue criminal prosecution.
- Maintain Documentation: Keep updating your harassment log and save any new evidence.
- Review Safety Plan: Develop or update a personal safety plan, including changing routines, securing your home, and using technology safely.
- Explore Counseling or Support Groups: Emotional distress caused by harassment can be significant. Consider professional counseling or support groups for victims of harassment.
Your Legal Rights in Massachusetts
- Civil Harassment: You have the right to seek a Harassment Prevention Order (HPO) to stop unwanted contact or behavior causing distress.
- Criminal Harassment: The state can prosecute someone who repeatedly and willfully harasses you, causing serious emotional distress.
- Protection from Violations: Violating an HPO is a criminal offense and can lead to arrest and prosecution.
- Right to Safety: You have a right to feel safe and free from harassment, and the law provides tools to protect you.
Note: The burden of proof is lower for civil harassment (preponderance of evidence) than for criminal harassment (beyond a reasonable doubt).
Where to Get Help
- Massachusetts Courts: Visit your local District or Probate and Family Court to file for a Harassment Prevention Order. Court clerks can assist with paperwork.
- Local Police Department: Report harassment and seek protection or advice on criminal charges.
- Massachusetts Legal Assistance Corporation (MLAC): Provides referrals to free or low-cost legal aid. Website: mlac.org
- Victim/Witness Assistance Programs: Many district attorneys’ offices have programs to support harassment victims.
- Domestic Violence and Harassment Hotlines: For immediate emotional support and safety planning:
- Massachusetts 24-Hour Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-877-785-2020
- National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233
- Private Attorneys: If possible, consult a lawyer specializing in harassment or criminal law for personalized advice.
Become a member
Join legal professionals, students, and researchers working together to create a comprehensive, open-source legal encyclopedia.
Sign Up