Under Pennsylvania law, there is no single statute that explicitly defines “good faith” scheduling for property retrieval by landlords, but relevant legal principles and best practices can be inferred from landlord-tenant regulations and case law.
Legal Framework for Property Retrieval
Notice and Access Requirements
- Notice to Tenant: When a tenant leaves personal property behind, Pennsylvania law (and related local ordinances) generally require landlords to provide written notice to the tenant, specifying that the property must be retrieved within a set period (often 30 days).
- Reasonable Access: During the notice period, landlords must provide reasonable access and opportunity for the tenant (or their authorized representative) to retrieve the property.
- Scheduling: The law does not specify exact hours or methods for scheduling, but “good faith” generally means the landlord must make a genuine effort to accommodate the tenant’s reasonable requests for access, within the bounds of practicality and safety.
What Constitutes “Good Faith” Scheduling
- Timely Communication: The landlord should promptly respond to the tenant’s requests to retrieve property and provide clear instructions on how and when access can be arranged.
- Flexibility: The landlord should offer reasonable flexibility in scheduling, such as providing multiple options for retrieval times, unless there are legitimate safety or operational concerns.
- No Unreasonable Obstruction: The landlord should not impose unnecessary barriers or delays to the tenant’s retrieval of property.
- Written Documentation: It is advisable for both parties to document all communications and agreements regarding property retrieval to avoid disputes.
Legal Consequences of Bad Faith
If a landlord acts in bad faith—such as by unreasonably denying access, failing to communicate, or intentionally obstructing the tenant’s retrieval of property—they may be liable for damages or other legal remedies. Courts may consider whether the landlord’s actions were reasonable and made in good faith when resolving disputes.
Summary Table
| Requirement | Good Faith Standard |
|---|---|
| Notice to Tenant | Written, clear, and timely |
| Access for Retrieval | Reasonable, flexible, documented |
| Communication | Prompt and clear |
| Obstruction | Avoided unless justified |
Key Takeaway
“Good faith” scheduling for property retrieval in Pennsylvania means the landlord must act honestly, provide reasonable notice and access, and avoid unnecessary obstacles to the tenant’s retrieval of their property. The specifics may vary by local ordinance, but the overarching principle is fairness and reasonableness.
🔴 Immediate Actions (Today or ASAP)
- Gather all documents and communications: Collect any written notices from your landlord about your property left behind, emails, texts, or letters regarding scheduling retrieval.
- Write a clear request to your landlord: Send a polite, written message (email or certified letter) asking for specific dates and times to retrieve your property. Keep a copy.
- Document everything: Keep records of all your attempts to communicate and their responses (or lack thereof).
- Review local ordinances: Check if your city or county has specific rules about landlord-tenant property retrieval that might provide extra protections.
🟡 Short-Term Steps (This Week)
- Follow up on your request: If you don’t get a timely response, send a polite follow-up message referencing your earlier communication.
- Propose flexible scheduling: Offer multiple reasonable dates and times to retrieve your property to demonstrate your willingness to cooperate.
- Consider a neutral witness: If possible, bring a friend or take photos/videos during retrieval to document the condition and access.
- Research your rights: Look up Pennsylvania landlord-tenant laws and any local rules about abandoned property to understand your protections.
🟢 Strategic Follow-Up (Next 2-4 Weeks or Longer)
- If landlord is uncooperative or obstructive: Consider sending a formal demand letter outlining your legal rights and requesting good faith scheduling.
- Seek legal advice: Contact a tenant rights organization or attorney to discuss possible remedies if your landlord refuses reasonable access.
- Prepare for possible legal action: If necessary, you may need to file a complaint in small claims court for damages or enforcement.
- Keep all documentation safe: Maintain a complete file of notices, communications, photos, and any expenses related to retrieving your property.
Your Legal Rights
- Under Pennsylvania law, landlords must provide written notice to tenants about property left behind and allow a reasonable period (often 30 days) to retrieve it.
- Landlords must offer reasonable access to the property and cannot unreasonably obstruct retrieval.
- "Good faith" means landlords should communicate promptly, be flexible with scheduling, and avoid unnecessary barriers.
- If a landlord acts in bad faith (e.g., denying access without reason), they may be liable for damages.
- Your communications and requests should be in writing to protect your rights.
Where to Get Help
- Pennsylvania Legal Aid Network (PLAN): Free or low-cost legal help for tenants. Visit palegalaid.net or call 1-877-429-5994.
- Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development: Information about landlord-tenant laws. Website: dced.pa.gov
- Local Tenant Rights Organizations: Search for tenant advocacy groups in your city or county.
- Consumer Protection Office: For complaints about landlord practices.
- Small Claims Court: For disputes involving property retrieval or damages.
Emergency Resource: If you feel threatened or unsafe during property retrieval, contact local law enforcement immediately.
Become a member
Join legal professionals, students, and researchers working together to create a comprehensive, open-source legal encyclopedia.
Sign Up