Insurance companies follow a structured process to investigate and assign fault after a car accident. The goal is to determine liability and decide which party or parties are responsible for covering damages. Here is how the process typically works:
Investigation Process
- Initial Claim Filing and Acknowledgment
- After a car accident, the involved parties file a claim with their respective insurance companies.
- The insurance company acknowledges the claim and begins an investigation, usually within a set timeframe (commonly 15 days from acknowledgment, but this can vary and may be extended).
- Evidence Collection
- Statements from Involved Parties: Insurance adjusters interview the drivers, passengers, and sometimes other individuals involved in the accident to gather their accounts of what happened.
- Witness Statements: Adjusters may also interview witnesses to corroborate or clarify details provided by the parties involved.
- Police Reports: The police report is a critical document, as it contains the official account of the accident, including observations from law enforcement and statements from those involved.
- Photographs and Video Evidence: Photos of the accident scene, vehicle damage, and any available video footage (such as dashcam or surveillance video) are reviewed to help reconstruct the event.
- Vehicle Inspection: Adjusters may inspect the vehicles involved to assess the extent and nature of the damage, which can help determine the mechanics of the collision.
- Traffic Laws and Accident Reconstruction: Adjusters consider relevant traffic laws and, in complex cases, may consult accident reconstruction experts to analyze how the accident occurred.
Assigning Fault
- Review of Evidence
- The insurance company reviews all collected evidence to assess liability.
- Adjusters look for violations of traffic laws (such as speeding, running a red light, or failing to yield), which are strong indicators of fault.
- Comparative Negligence
- In many jurisdictions, fault can be shared between parties. If both drivers contributed to the accident, each may be assigned a percentage of fault (e.g., 30% and 70%).
- Compensation may be reduced according to the percentage of fault assigned to each party.
- Decision and Communication
- Once the investigation is complete, the insurance company communicates its decision regarding fault and liability to the involved parties.
- If there are discrepancies between the claimant’s account and the insurer’s findings, the claim may be denied or a reduced settlement may be offered.
Summary Table
| Step | Description |
|---|---|
| Claim Filing | Parties submit claims to their insurance companies |
| Evidence Collection | Interviews, witness statements, police reports, photos, video, inspections |
| Review of Evidence | Analysis of all collected information and traffic laws |
| Fault Assignment | Determination of liability, possibly with shared fault |
| Communication of Decision | Insurer informs parties of fault determination and settlement options |
This process ensures that insurance companies make informed decisions based on available evidence and applicable laws.
🔴 Immediate Actions (Today or ASAP)
- File Your Claim Promptly: Contact your insurance company immediately to report the accident if you haven't already. Provide all basic details accurately.
- Gather Evidence: Collect and preserve any evidence you have: photos of the accident scene and vehicle damage, contact info of witnesses, and a copy of the police report if available.
- Document Your Account: Write down your detailed version of what happened while it’s fresh in your mind. Include date, time, location, weather, and any other relevant details.
- Avoid Admitting Fault: When speaking with insurance adjusters or the other party, stick to the facts and do not admit fault or speculate.
🟡 Short-Term Steps (This Week)
- Communicate in Writing: Follow up with your insurer in writing (email or letter) to confirm your claim details and keep a record.
- Obtain Police Report: Request a copy of the official police report from the law enforcement agency if you don’t have it yet.
- Provide Requested Information: Respond promptly and fully to any requests from your insurance company for statements, documents, or vehicle inspections.
- Keep Detailed Records: Maintain a file with all correspondence, medical bills, repair estimates, and notes related to the accident and claim.
- Consider Consulting a Lawyer: If you suspect the fault assignment may be unfair or your claim is denied, consult a personal injury or insurance attorney early.
🟢 Strategic Follow-Up (Next 2-4 Weeks or Longer)
- Review Fault Assignment: Once the insurance company communicates its fault decision, review it carefully. Compare it with your evidence and the police report.
- Dispute if Needed: If you disagree with the fault determination or settlement offer, submit a formal dispute or appeal to the insurer with supporting evidence.
- Consider Mediation or Legal Action: If disputes are unresolved, explore mediation or consult an attorney about filing a lawsuit or complaint with your state insurance department.
- Monitor Claim Progress: Stay in contact with your insurer to track claim status and ensure timely resolution.
Your Legal Rights
- Right to Fair Investigation: Insurance companies must investigate claims fairly and in good faith under state insurance laws.
- Right to Access Evidence: You can request copies of evidence used in fault determination, including police reports and inspection reports.
- Right to Dispute: You have the right to dispute an insurer’s fault assignment or claim denial and request reconsideration.
- Comparative Negligence: Many states use comparative negligence rules, meaning fault can be shared and compensation adjusted accordingly.
- Protection from Bad Faith: Insurers cannot deny claims or delay payments without a reasonable basis; doing so may be bad faith insurance practices.
Where to Get Help
- State Insurance Department: Contact your state’s insurance regulator to file complaints or get guidance. Visit the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) website to find your state office.
- Legal Aid Organizations: If you cannot afford a lawyer, look for local legal aid groups that provide free or low-cost advice on insurance claims and personal injury.
- Consumer Protection Agencies: Your state’s consumer protection office can help with unfair insurance practices.
- Personal Injury Attorneys: For serious disputes or injury claims, consult a lawyer experienced in car accident cases. Many offer free initial consultations.
- Police Department: For copies of the accident report and related information.
Become a member
Join legal professionals, students, and researchers working together to create a comprehensive, open-source legal encyclopedia.
Sign Up