The key differences between vehicle theft and wrongful towing or sale by property managers lie in the nature of the act, legal authority, and the rights involved:
| Aspect | Vehicle Theft | Wrongful Towing/Sale by Property Managers |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of Act | Unauthorized and criminal taking of a vehicle with intent to permanently deprive the owner of it. | Removal or sale of a vehicle by a towing company or property manager, often under a claim of lien or property rules, but potentially without proper legal authority or procedure. |
| Legal Authority | No legal authority; outright illegal and criminal. | May have some legal basis (e.g., possessory lien for towing/storage fees), but can be wrongful if procedures or laws (like signage, notice, or statutory requirements) are not followed. |
| Possessory Lien | Not applicable. | Towing companies acting under statutes (e.g., GS 20-219.2) acquire a possessory lien allowing retention and potential sale if fees are unpaid. However, if towing is outside statutory authority, lien and sale rights may be unclear or invalid. |
| Owner's Rights | Owner has full right to possession; theft violates these rights. | Owner may contest towing or sale if wrongful; laws often provide mechanisms to challenge improper towing or sale (e.g., Vehicle Code section 22658). |
| Legal Claims Against Perpetrator | Criminal charges for theft; civil claims for conversion or replevin. | Civil claims for wrongful towing, breach of contract, negligence, conversion, or statutory damages; possible criminal charges if theft of items occurs during towing. |
| Examples of Wrongful Acts | Taking vehicle without permission to permanently deprive owner. | Towing without proper signage or notice, illegal "roving" towing, failure to follow statutory procedures, selling vehicle without proper lien or notice. |
| Possible Remedies | Criminal prosecution, recovery of vehicle, damages for loss. | Contest towing in court, recover vehicle, sue for damages, challenge improper sale, seek statutory penalties against property managers or towing companies. |
In summary, vehicle theft is a criminal act involving unauthorized permanent taking, while wrongful towing or sale by property managers involves potentially unlawful removal or sale of a vehicle under disputed or improper legal authority. Wrongful towing often involves civil disputes over compliance with specific laws and procedures, whereas theft is a clear violation of property rights and criminal law.
🔴 Immediate Actions (Today or ASAP)
- Document Everything: Take photos of your vehicle’s current location (if still on property) or the towing notice/receipt if it was towed.
- Gather Paperwork: Find your vehicle registration, proof of ownership, insurance, and any communication related to the towing or property rules.
- Contact the Towing Company or Property Manager: Call or visit to ask for the reason for towing, where your vehicle is, and what fees or steps are needed to get it back.
- Request Written Notice: If you haven’t received a written notice explaining the towing and your rights, ask for one immediately.
- Do Not Pay or Sign Anything Without Understanding: Avoid paying fees or signing documents until you confirm the towing was lawful.
🟡 Short-Term Steps (This Week)
- Review Local Laws: Look up your state’s vehicle and towing laws (e.g., Vehicle Code section 22658 or GS 20-219.2) to understand if the towing company or property manager followed legal procedures.
- Send a Formal Letter or Email: Write a clear letter to the towing company and property manager disputing wrongful towing or sale, requesting return of your vehicle and any fees charged. Keep a copy. Example:
"I am the rightful owner of the vehicle towed from [location] on [date]. I dispute the towing because [reason, e.g., no proper notice]. Please return my vehicle immediately and provide all documentation related to the towing and any fees charged." - Check for Signage and Notices: Verify if the property had proper signs about towing rules as required by law.
- Contact Your Insurance: Inform your insurance company about the towing; they may assist or advise.
- Consider Filing a Complaint: If you believe the towing was wrongful, file a complaint with your local consumer protection agency or the state’s towing regulation authority.
🟢 Strategic Follow-Up (Next 2-4 Weeks or Longer)
- Consult an Attorney: If the towing company or property manager refuses to return your vehicle or you suspect illegal sale, consult a lawyer experienced in vehicle law or consumer rights.
- File a Lawsuit if Necessary: You may file a civil suit for wrongful towing, conversion (illegal taking), or breach of contract to recover your vehicle or damages.
- Monitor for Vehicle Sale: If your vehicle is at risk of being sold, act quickly to stop the sale through legal injunctions if advised by your attorney.
- Keep Records: Maintain all correspondence, receipts, photos, and notes about phone calls or visits regarding the towing dispute.
- Know Your Rights for Future Prevention: Learn about proper towing procedures and your rights to avoid wrongful towing in the future.
Your Legal Rights
- Right to Possession: You have the right to possess your vehicle and to be notified properly before towing or sale.
- Legal Procedures Required: Property managers and towing companies must follow state laws (like Vehicle Code section 22658) including signage, notice, and proper lien procedures.
- Right to Challenge Wrongful Towing: You can dispute a towing or sale that did not follow legal rules through administrative complaints or court actions.
- Protection Against Theft: If your vehicle was taken without any legal authority, it is theft, a criminal offense that you can report to police.
- Right to Damages: You may be entitled to recover money for wrongful towing, loss of use, or improper sale of your vehicle.
Where to Get Help
- Local Police: Report suspected vehicle theft or illegal towing.
- State Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV): They often regulate towing companies and handle complaints.
- State Attorney General’s Office: Consumer protection division can assist with wrongful towing complaints.
- Legal Aid Organizations: Look for free or low-cost legal help in your area for consumer or vehicle law issues.
- Better Business Bureau (BBB): File complaints against towing companies or property managers.
- Small Claims Court: For disputes involving fees or damages under a certain amount, you can file a claim yourself.
Become a member
Join legal professionals, students, and researchers working together to create a comprehensive, open-source legal encyclopedia.
Sign Up